› Whether 'youth' in 1873 deed of trust was gender-neutral or referred to boys only
› Whether deed precluded admission of girls to school
Equity
› Trusts and trustees
› Trust instrument
› Interpretation
› Surrounding circumstances
› Whether surrounding circumstances required departure from ordinary meaning of language
› Whether subsequent conduct of parties admissible to construe trust deed
› Ancient documents rule
› Whether rule enlivened absent ambiguity
Evidence
› Admissibility
› Newspaper articles as evidence of contemporaneous usage of a word
› Whether selective newspaper quotations admissible to establish meaning of term in trust deed
› Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 135
Quick Take
The word 'youth' in a 19th century trust deed is unambiguously gender-neutral, and the ancient documents rule cannot be used to create ambiguities that the construing judge does not consider exist.