TORTS — Trespass to the person — False Imprisonment — Wrongful arrest — Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW) (LEPRA) s. 201 and s. 202 — Obligation to provide the reason for arrest as soon as it is reasonably practicable to do so
Quick Take
1Under s 202 of LEPRA, where the arrested person's own conduct (here, reaching for the ignition key and physically resisting) makes it practically impossible for the arresting officer to communicate the reason for arrest, it is not 'reasonably practicable' to provide that reason until the person is restrained, and the arrest remains lawful in the interim.
2What constitutes a sufficient statement of 'the reason for the exercise of the power' under s 202(1)(c) LEPRA depends on the particular circumstances, including the arrested person's prior dealings with the arresting officer and likely knowledge of the alleged offence; on the facts, telling the arrestee he was under arrest for 'breach AVO' was sufficient where the same officer had detected the breach only weeks earlier in circumstances the arrestee would have remembered.
3The question whether an arrest that is lawful up to the point where reasons are given, but where the reasons given are later found insufficient, can ground a continuing lawful detention for resisting arrest committed during the initially lawful period was identified but left open as it was not fully argued.