The Commission found that the dismissal of a retained firefighter captain for domestic violence convictions was harsh, though not unjust or unreasonable, because the employer failed to genuinely consider alternative disciplinary measures, the offending occurred in an acute personal crisis unrelated to duties, and the employer's own prior non-compliance with a reinstatement order and creation of an unworkable co-captaincy arrangement contributed to workplace dysfunction. Reinstatement was found impracticable due to entrenched interpersonal conflict and breakdown of trust, and compensation of 8 weeks' ordinary remuneration was awarded in lieu. The decision confirms that criminal convictions constituting misconduct under the Fire and Rescue NSW Regulation 2023 do not automatically justify termination where proportionality and mitigating factors, including 40 years of service, weigh against it.
The full text is available to signed-in members.