The Court held that consent orders made on a 'without admission' basis can still constitute capitulation for costs purposes where the substance of the orders substantially accords with the relief sought by the applicant, applying the [name withheld] v [name withheld] principle that success is evaluated by looking to the substance of outcomes sought and obtained rather than precise terms. The Court also held that an amendment narrowing the applicant's case did not alter the characterisation of capitulation where the substantive relief remained unchanged. A gross sum costs order was declined notwithstanding the respondent's non-compliance with directions and vacation of hearing dates, as such conduct alone was insufficient justification.
The full text is available to signed-in members.