The Court found Delta Electricity guilty under s 64(1) of the POEO Act for failing to maintain its chlorine dosing plant in a proper and efficient condition, specifically by failing to maintain valve 11800 so that it closed on demand and operated in a way that minimised the risk of uncontrolled sodium hypochlorite discharge into the environment. The honest and reasonable mistake of fact defence failed because the defendant could not establish an affirmative belief that the valve was functioning correctly as at the date of the incident — a mere lack of knowledge or general understanding that everything was in order was held insufficient, following State Rail Authority v Hunter Water Board. The Court did not find proven the particular alleging a design deficiency in the absence of diagnostic tools for identifying valve failures.
The full text is available to signed-in members.