The Commissioner upheld the appeal against Council's refusal of a 70-place childcare centre DA, finding that the internal design adequately facilitated supervision of children under Regulation 115 of the Education and Care Services National Regulations, that construction traffic impacts were transitory and manageable via a CTMP, and that 93 public objections did not warrant refusal given compliance with applicable planning controls. The Court accepted that CCTV conditions provided an additional safeguard but were not a substitute for adequate passive design and active supervision. On the construction amenity contention, the Court gave little weight to the respondent's planning expert's evidence, finding it lacked explicit analysis and preferring the agreed evidence of the traffic engineers.
The full text is available to signed-in members.