The Commission determined that C5/6 anterior cervical discectomy and fusion surgery and L5/S1 right sided microdiscectomy were reasonably necessary as a result of the accepted workplace injury, applying the commonsense test of causation and the [name withheld] criteria of reasonableness. The bilateral lumbar and SIJ blocks were found not reasonably necessary on the basis that they would provide only temporary relief in circumstances where the applicant intended to proceed to surgery. The Commission preferred the opinions of three treating/examining specialists over the respondent's forensic expert, finding the latter's diagnosis of a resolved temporary aggravation was inconsistent with over two years of unremitting symptoms and the comparative MRI evidence showing worsened pathology.
The full text is available to signed-in members.