1A lease clause restricting dealings in the shares of 'the Lessee', and actions changing control by 'the shareholders of the Lessee', applies only to changes in the immediate shareholding of the lessee entity. It does not extend to a sale of shares several levels upstream in the corporate group, and broad notions of commercial purpose cannot force onto the words a meaning they do not bear.
2Where no obligation to obtain consent arises, a lessee's statement that an upstream transaction will proceed regardless of consent, while its request for consent remains on foot, does not convey to a reasonable person a renunciation of the lease and is not repudiation.
3[name withheld] v Cohen was applied at first instance despite the criticism of it, but on the facts it did not ground liability in nuisance: the drains lay below the depth limit of the leased and licensed areas, so the lessee neither occupied that land nor bore any repair obligation for it, and there was no evidence the building became dangerous. Matters of pre-wrong maintenance are not properly characterised as a failure to mitigate, though they may bear on apportionment.
Case Details
Citation[2025] NSWSC 1388
CourtNSWSC
JurisdictionNew South Wales
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.