1Where a defendant successfully opposes a plaintiff's primary claim and the defendant's cross-claims were advanced only as alternative relief contingent on failure of the primary defence, the overall result is properly characterised as a complete success for the defendant, and the plaintiff should bear the costs of the entire proceedings including the dismissed cross-claims.
2A Calderbank offer proposing alternative relief (such as partition rather than sale) is not more favourable than the result achieved by a defendant whose primary case — that no trustee for sale should be appointed at all — succeeds, even though the defendant's own alternative cross-claims for partition were dismissed.
3Costs incurred in relation to cross-claims that would not have been brought but for the plaintiff commencing proceedings are properly borne by the unsuccessful plaintiff, consistent with the distinction drawn in [name withheld] v Australian Broadcasting Corp (No 2) between successful defendants and successful plaintiffs in multi-issue litigation.