The Court held that a dispute resolution clause requiring expert determination of disputes 'about' a strata management statement was narrower in scope than a separate clause covering disputes 'about matters arising from' the SMS, and that the shift in language implied a shift in legal meaning. The dispute concerning whether a strata managing agent had authority to convene BMC meetings was characterised as being about the scope of the agency agreement rather than 'about' the SMS itself, and accordingly the mandatory expert determination procedure was not engaged. The Court also observed that the strata managing agent, not being a party to the SMS, could not be compelled to participate in any expert determination, which was a relevant discretionary consideration.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.