The Court made a gross sum costs order of $122,673 against the plaintiffs and a personal costs order of $73,603 against their solicitor under CPA s 99, finding the solicitor's conduct involved serious neglect and incompetence in pressing reliance on a stale statutory demand, filing manifestly defective 74-page pleadings containing unsupported allegations of misconduct against non-parties, and prosecuting proceedings in a manner that caused significant wasted costs. The Court found that citing AI-hallucinated authorities, while a serious matter, had little practical impact on costs incurred by the opposing party. The solicitor's claim that he acted on instructions was held to be no answer to maintaining untenable claims and untenable pleadings.
The full text is available to signed-in members.