The Court struck out a statement of claim that sought to revisit final orders of [name withheld] determining equitable compensation for a proprietary estoppel interest in land, holding that cause of action estoppel absolutely barred the plaintiff's attempt to relitigate the quantum of compensation by reference to subsequent valuation evidence. The Court confirmed that fresh evidence obtained after final orders cannot ground a first-instance application to vary those orders, and that no basis existed under UCPR r 36.15 (irregularly entered orders) or in equity (unconscionability) to set aside or vary the earlier orders. Leave to replead was granted only in respect of a separate claim for missing equipment/chattels (valued below $69,000), which was transferred to the Local Court.
The full text is available to signed-in members.