Treatment and Care of Persons with Impaired Capacity
where the respondent is a 13 year old child
where the applicant seeks orders permitting the staff of the applicant to terminate the respondent’s pregnancy
Quick Take
1Because the Termination of Pregnancy Act 2018 (Qld) makes no relevant provision about consent, the general law governs consent to a termination for a minor. Since it is doubtful a parent can consent on a child's behalf, the Supreme Court's parens patriae jurisdiction, which does not extend to an unborn child, may be invoked to authorise the procedure.
2A minor is Gillick competent only if she has sufficient maturity and understanding to understand fully what is proposed, including the long-term consequences of both terminating and continuing the pregnancy; intelligence alone is not enough. On the facts, a 13-year-old whose reasons were short-term and rudimentary, and who could not explain consent, was not competent.
3Section 26(2) of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) (a child's right to protection in their best interests) is not inconsistent with the parens patriae best interests jurisdiction, and s 106 preserves laws relating to termination of pregnancy. The Court did not need to decide more broadly whether the Act otherwise affects the jurisdiction.