1The principles governing 'reasonably necessary' under former s 180 of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) remain relevant to s 180 of the Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), notwithstanding the new provision's different language and additional criteria. Those principles include objective assessment, more than mere desirability, a question of degree, and the greater the burden the stronger the case required.
2The registered owner's indefeasible title over the burdened land does not answer an application under s 180, which is an ameliorative provision permitting limited rights to be imposed over land despite indefeasibility. On the facts, an easement was reasonably necessary where a long-used shared driveway was the only vehicle and practical pedestrian access to rear parking, and alternative access would require demolition of a building regulated by a commercial character overlay.
3Under s 180(13), the facts that make a refusal unreasonable for the purposes of s 180(5)(e)–(f) will not, without more, constitute special circumstances. However, special circumstances may exist where the respondent appeared by a non-lawyer director and incurred no legal costs, since costs are only a partial indemnity for professional legal costs actually incurred (Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow; Birketu Pty Ltd v Atanaskovic).