Separate Decision or Determination of Questions and Consolidation of Proceedings
Separate Decision or Determination
Quick Take
1Under r 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), the party seeking a separate decision bears the onus of showing it is just and convenient. The starting point is that all issues of fact and law are determined at one trial, and an order should be made only where utility, economy and fairness are clearly made out.
2Separate determination is inappropriate where it would merely reallocate rather than save time and expense, where it would not clearly dispose of the proceeding, and where the same contractual construction issue would remain to be decided at trial. Here the question was whether a second mortgagee's claim was premature until the first mortgagee had sold the whole security and an account could be taken.
3On the facts, the risk that an appeal from a preliminary determination would delay final resolution, together with a short trial listed about five weeks away, outweighed any possible advantage of a separate hearing. The court did not decide whether the principle in Adams v Bank of New South Wales [1984] 1 NSWLR 285 against partial accounts applied.