The Court held that where a prior appeal against the same Magistrates Court conviction had been dismissed for want of prosecution but the appeal judge also expressed a view that the appeal lacked merit on the papers, this amounted to a consideration of the appeal on its merits, depriving the Court of jurisdiction to hear a second appeal under s 42(1) of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA). In the alternative, the Court held that even if jurisdiction existed, the limited exception in R v [name withheld] permitting reopening of a summarily dismissed appeal would not be exercised where the appellant's non-attendance was not due to exceptional circumstances, no denial of procedural fairness occurred, and no clear injustice was demonstrated. The Court also found the appeal lacked merit in any event.
The full text is available to signed-in members.