› Risk of dissipation – danger of disposal or diminution – effect not purpose of dealing determines jurisdiction
Equity
› Trusts
› Trustee's right of exoneration – priority over beneficiaries' vested and indefeasible entitlements – distributions to beneficiaries
Civil procedure
› Freezing orders
› Carve-outs for legal and business expenses – specific asset orders – evidential burden on defendant
Civil procedure
› Freezing orders
› Ancillary asset disclosure orders – no order against director where only company asset frozen
Quick Take
1The jurisdictional requirement for a freezing order is met where the effect of a proposed dealing creates a danger that a prospective judgment will be wholly or partly unsatisfied. The purpose or justifiability of the dealing goes only to discretion, and paying ordinary third-party trade debts (such as GST) in the ordinary course will generally not justify freezing relief.
2A trustee's prospective payment of beneficiaries' vested and indefeasible entitlements can support a freezing order, because a claimant against the trustee arguably enjoys priority over beneficiaries through the trustee's right of exoneration from trust assets (Carter Holt Harvey). Claimed prejudice to beneficiaries carries no weight absent evidence that they cannot meet their tax liabilities by other means.
3The 'usual' carve-outs for legal and business expenses are commonplace for maximum-sum orders but not automatic where only a specific asset is frozen. Whether to allow them is a question of what is just and convenient, and the defendant bears an evidential burden to show it lacks sufficient other assets. On the facts, a special-purpose trustee with no other assets was permitted recourse to the frozen funds.
Case Details
Citation[2025] VSC 721
CourtVSC
JurisdictionVictoria
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.
1 of the 1 citing case carries a classified treatment. How each court treated it is available to signed-in members.