› Freezing orders – discharge on return date – onus on applicant to justify continuation
Civil procedure
› Freezing orders
› Danger of unsatisfied judgment – unjustified dissipation – payments in ordinary course of business
Civil procedure
› Freezing orders
› Good arguable case – claim to whole of insurance proceeds by tenant in common
Insurance
› Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) s 49
› Indemnity principle – co-owned property – entitlement to proceeds
Quick Take
1An applicant seeking to continue a freezing order bears the onus of showing a good arguable case on admissible evidence. A bare assertion that the whole of the insurance proceeds is owed to one co-owner, supported only by payment of the premium and unexplained in the face of s 49 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) and the indemnity principle, was insufficient on the facts.
2Expenditure of disputed funds in the ordinary course of business is not 'unjustified dissipation' warranting a freezing order. That is particularly so where the payments are consistent with historical transactions predating the dispute. A freezing order is not to be used to stop a respondent paying its debts or ordinary operating expenses.
3Where a respondent has had complete control of disputed funds for a long period with knowledge of the claim, and has not taken steps to dissipate them all, it is difficult to infer an intention to stultify a future judgment. A substantially reduced amount in dispute, readily covered by the respondent's other assets, also weighs against continuing the order.
Case Details
Citation[2025] VSC 727
CourtVSC
JurisdictionVictoria
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.