› Reckless conduct endangering life — unsafe storage of loaded homemade firearm in family home
Criminal law
› Sentence
› Prohibited person in possession of firearm — overlap with reckless endangerment — avoidance of double punishment — totality
Criminal law
› Sentence
› Death not element or aggravating factor — novus actus interveniens — victim impact confined to offences charged
Criminal law
› Sentence
› Mitigation — Koori Court shaming by elders — extra-curial punishment — manslaughter charge hanging over accused — Bugmy — Verdins
Quick Take
1Where an offender's unsafe storage of a loaded gun was a causa sine qua non of a death, but the victim's deliberate and unforeseeable act of throwing or dropping the gun was a novus actus interveniens, the offender must not be sentenced for causing the death. The death is neither an element nor an aggravating factor, and serves only to illustrate how dangerous the conduct was. Victim impact is confined to harm resulting directly from the endangerment and firearm offences, not from the death.
2Reckless endangerment arising from a state of affairs, such as secreting a loaded weapon where another must mishandle it for the danger to materialise, is qualitatively less serious than active, immediate and dynamic dangerous conduct. On the facts, the absence of any intention to frighten or harm, and Bugmy considerations, modestly reduced moral culpability.
3Several matters may mitigate a sentence: shaming and admonishment by elders in a Koori Court sentencing conversation; the prolonged strain of a later-abandoned manslaughter charge; and the loss, through delay, of the chance of partial concurrency with later prison sentences. Extra-curial punishment may also prevent Bugmy-related factors from increasing the weight given to community protection.