The Court held that where a trust deed defines 'Assets' broadly to include all property and rights of the trust, and precludes unit holders from claiming any interest in or exercising rights in respect of an Asset, the proprietary approach to beneficiary inspection of trust documents does not apply, following AIT Investment Group. Under the discretionary approach applying the [name withheld] v [name withheld] factors, the Court declined to order further production where the trustee had already substantially responded to document requests across multiple categories, the beneficiary could not articulate what specific further documents remained outstanding, and the manner in which requests had been pursued (including raising a new formulation for the first time at trial) weighed against the exercise of discretion. The Court noted that a beneficiary's legitimate interest in monitoring trust administration, including to support potential amendment of claims, is not itself a disqualifying purpose, but that interest must be balanced against the cost and burden imposed on the trustee and other beneficiaries.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 2 later cases that cite this judgment.