The Court found that four breaches of a non-solicitation order were not contumacious where the defendant genuinely but mistakenly believed the clients contacted fell outside the order's scope, had developed a self-policing mechanism to comply, immediately admitted breaches when notified, and voluntarily disclosed further breaches. No penalty was imposed on condition the defendant pay $4,653.00 (the financial benefit obtained from one client) to the plaintiff within seven days. No costs order was made against either party, the Court finding that contempt proceedings were not necessary to achieve compliance and the circumstances did not demand punishment, though the evidence had at least raised the possibility of contumacious conduct.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.