The Judicial Registrar dismissed the plaintiff's application for specific discovery across all four categories in a whistleblower protection claim under Pt 9.4AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The Court held that documents relating to the restructure and redundancy of the Indian business unit and comparator employees were not relevant to any fact in issue on the pleadings, because the plaintiff's claim was confined to alleged detrimental conduct at a specific September 2021 meeting rather than the fact of redundancy itself. Documents relating to the plaintiff's tax treatment were also refused on the basis that the underlying tax liabilities had been resolved (save for a $76,000 ATO penalty), and that internal documents about NBN Co's actual motives or decision-making regarding tax compliance were not probative of whether the plaintiff had 'reasonable grounds to suspect' misconduct at the time of his disclosures under s 1317AA of the Corporations Act.
The full text is available to signed-in members.