The Court refused to modify a single-dwelling restrictive covenant under s 84(1)(c) of the Property Law Act 1958 (Vic), holding that the proposed two-dwelling development on a prominent corner lot would cause substantial injury to beneficiaries both through direct impairment of the garden suburb neighbourhood character and through significant precedential effect, with the Court identifying eight comparable lots in the subdivision and three in an adjacent subdivision as potential candidates for similar applications. The Court held that the introduction of planning amendment VC267, which removed council discretion to refuse multi-dwelling developments meeting minimum standards, materially increased the value of single-dwelling covenants as the sole remaining bulwark against intensification, such that diminishing or removing the covenant in that changed planning context must of itself amount to substantial injury. The Court also clarified that while town planning principles and amenity controls are not relevant to the substantial injury inquiry, the broader planning context — including the availability or unavailability of alternative remedies — is relevant to assessing the realistic consequences of modification.
The full text is available to signed-in members.