The Court refused bail on a murder charge, holding that the applicant failed to establish exceptional circumstances under s 4A(1A) of the Bail Act 1977 (Vic). While onerous custodial conditions (limited runout time, LTMP classification), serious physical injuries sustained during the incident, a diagnosis of PTSD, deficiencies in medical care provision, youth, absence of prior convictions, family support, and a $1 million bail guarantee were acknowledged as important, these were outweighed by the very serious nature of the alleged planned shooting murder, the apparent strength of the prosecution case (including DNA evidence linking the applicant to the scene), the inevitability of a lengthy sentence upon conviction, and factors raising concerns about flight risk and public safety, including possible organised crime connections. The Court held that police intelligence material set out in the informant's report, though subject to PII, was admissible under s 8(1)(e) of the Act and could properly inform the assessment of risk at both steps of the bail process, and that the presence or absence of risk factors is relevant to the exceptional circumstances inquiry.
The full text is available to signed-in members.