The prohibition notice was upheld but varied in duration to operate only from 12 February 2025 to 28 March 2025. The Tribunal held that in ACT administrative merits review of a WHS prohibition notice under s 195 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011, the Tribunal stands in the shoes of the decision-maker and decides for itself whether a reasonable belief is warranted, rather than reviewing whether the original inspector validly formed such a belief — expressly declining to follow several NSW IRC decisions that treated the inspector's state of mind as a jurisdictional prerequisite. Section 195(1)(b) contains a temporal element requiring the Tribunal to assess the reasonable belief as at the date the prohibition notice issued, limiting admissible evidence to material in existence at that time. The 'reasonable belief' standard requires objective circumstances pointing more clearly than suspicion but falling short of proof on the balance of probabilities, and the inspector is not required to conduct a full investigation or confirm that remedial steps were actually taken.
The full text is available to signed-in members.