The appeal was dismissed and the orders of the Original Tribunal confirming the Commissioner's disallowance of the objection to the duty assessment were confirmed. The Appeal Tribunal held that s 232D(2)–(3) of the Duties Act 1999 (ACT) does not provide any exemption or reduction in stamp duty for transfers of dutiable property that give effect to a beneficiary's share of an undifferentiated residual estate, because such transfers cannot be 'in conformity' or 'partly in conformity' with the trusts in the will — conformity requires a specific devise or gift of the dutiable property itself. While the Tribunal reached the same result as the Original Tribunal, it did so on different reasoning, finding that neither the appellant's nor the Commissioner's interpretation of 'Y' in the s 232D(3) formula was correct, and expressly stated that if the legislature intends s 232D to apply to residual estate distributions, legislative amendment is required.
The full text is available to signed-in members.