application seeking to give effect to a motion defeated at Annual General Meeting
merits review of the unsuccessful motion
maintenance of Class A and Class B units
Quick Take
1Under s 129(1)(g) of the Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011, the Tribunal undertakes a four-step process: merits review of the defeated motion; determination whether opposition was unreasonable; decision whether to exercise the discretion to give effect to the motion; and determination whether to give effect to the motion as put or as amended.
2The standard of 'unreasonable' in s 129(1)(g) is the ordinary dictionary meaning — not guided by reason or good sense — and not the heightened Wednesbury standard from administrative law, because separation of powers considerations underpinning Wednesbury have no application to tribunal review of owners corporation decisions.
3Opposition to a motion that is based on subjective perceptions, historical mistrust and misinterpretation of the motion's effect — rather than any objectively identifiable detriment to the opponents' interests — is unreasonable within the meaning of s 129(1)(g).