The first applicant tenant was removed from the co-tenancy with immediate effect, but his claim for compensation (reimbursement of rent paid while the lessor unreasonably refused consent to add a replacement co-tenant) was dismissed for want of jurisdiction. The Tribunal held that while the lessor's blanket refusal to consider adding a co-tenant was generally unreasonable, the RT Act confers no express power to award compensation when a lessor's refusal to add a co-tenant is overturned, and the residual power in s 83(1)(m) cannot be used to fill that gap where the legislature has enacted a detailed specific framework. The decision also signals that a lessor's failure to prepare updated condition reports between consecutive tenancies is unlikely to constitute a reasonable ground for refusing a co-tenant addition, and that proposals to terminate a fixed-term tenancy or require tenants to vacate for inspections may themselves breach the tenancy agreement. The question whether a lessor can refuse consent under s 35C where the proposed co-tenant's identity is not provided was raised but expressly left open.
The full text is available to signed-in members.