The Appeal Tribunal held that the Original Tribunal erred in finding no 'condition or requirement' for indirect discrimination purposes merely because alternative accessible pathways existed; the requirement to navigate uneven pavers to access a particular public area itself constitutes a condition or requirement that disadvantages persons with mobility disabilities. However, the error was not material because the condition was reasonable in the circumstances, given the respondent's maintenance and inspection regime, the availability of alternative accessible pathways, and the inherent possibility of pavers becoming uneven. The case confirms that the availability of alternatives goes to reasonableness under s 8(4)-(5) of the Discrimination Act 1991 (ACT), not to the threshold question of whether a condition or requirement exists.
The full text is available to signed-in members.