The Tribunal varied the Commissioner's decision by remitting the 25% penalty tax ($4,426) in full, while upholding the reassessment of duty and interest. The key holdings are: (1) 'total gross income' under s 6(1)(c) of the HBCS (DI2021-172) means income from all sources before deductions, not taxable income as shown on ATO notices of assessment; (2) the two requirements in s 6(1)(c) — that total gross income be at or below the threshold and that it reflect usual income — are cumulative, and failure on the first is dispositive; (3) a taxpayer's failure to discharge the onus of proving 'reasonable care' under s 31(5)(a) does not preclude full remission of penalty tax under s 37; and (4) in exercising the s 37 discretion, the Tribunal must balance general and specific deterrent value against the taxpayer's culpability and hardship, and subsequent legislative amendments that would have rendered the taxpayer's interpretation correct are relevant to reducing the deterrent value of the penalty.
The full text is available to signed-in members.