Appeal from the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal
allegations of discourteous conduct in telephone calls
Quick Take
1Rule 32 of the Legal Profession (Solicitors) Conduct Rules 2015 (ACT) raises three questions: (1) whether the allegation is, in substance and context, one of unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct, without any need to use those terms; (2) whether it was made bona fide; and (3) whether the practitioner had reasonable grounds, judged on the information known at the time, for believing that available material provided a proper basis for it. An honest but unreasonable belief still breaches the rule.
2Making allegations in a response to a regulator's complaint is not exempt from r 32. A robust defence never requires unfounded allegations against another practitioner. Whether a breach amounts to unsatisfactory professional conduct depends on the circumstances. On the facts, a considered response prepared over several weeks, rather than 'in the moment', fell outside the tolerable range of error.
3In civil disciplinary proceedings, the 'might be true' limb of a Liberato direction has no application. Rejecting a respondent's evidence does not shift the onus of proof. The rejected evidence need not necessarily be 'put to one side', given the practitioner's duties of candour and reasonable assistance, subject to procedural fairness.