where ASIC reached agreement on liability and relief with the third defendant
where the third defendant agreed to an increase in the insurance premiums payable by one of the ACBF Entities to Crown
whether the third defendant failed to consider the effect of the financial arrangements with Crown on the ACBF Entities and failed to consider or pursue alternative insurance arrangements
Quick Take
1A director or financial controller who knows of a principal's conflict of interest, and allows a related-party insurer's premium increase to proceed without analysing its effect on the company or considering alternatives (renegotiation, alternative insurer, self-insurance, fee reductions or winding up), may contravene s 180(1). On the admitted facts, such conduct also contravened ss 181(1) and 182(1), even though the officer did not intend to breach his duties and derived no personal benefit.
2In fixing disqualification and penalty among co-defendants, a defendant's subordinate role, short period of contravention, absence of personal profit and early cooperation warrant lower relief than the primary decision-maker. Senior financial responsibility and insight into the entities' finances may nonetheless justify a longer disqualification than that imposed on other co-defendants.
3Where contraventions of three civil penalty provisions relate to a single entity and trace back to a single cause, they may be treated as a single course of conduct for each entity. Applying established principle, an agreed penalty within the permissible range will be accepted (Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2021] FCAFC 49; 284 FCR 24 at [127]).