The Court of Appeal refused leave for a self-represented litigant to issue a subpoena to produce documents concerning alleged transcript tampering, holding that the subpoena lacked a legitimate forensic purpose because the primary judge's summary dismissal had not turned on any factual finding about transcript tampering but rather on legal grounds (immunity, limitation periods, and inadequacy of pleaded relief) that assumed the truth of the plaintiff's allegations. A subpoena must be directed to the particular issues to be determined in the appeal and cannot be justified by reference to a freestanding investigation into alleged miscarriage of justice.
The full text is available to signed-in members.