The appeal was dismissed and the appellant was ordered to pay the first respondent's costs, upholding the primary judge's finding that a $1 million oral loan was made to the appellant personally (not to his company) and was repayable after three months, defeating the limitation defence. Post-contractual documents — including a cheque made out to the borrower's company, financial statements prepared by an external accountant identifying the company as borrower, and a reconciliation spreadsheet — were held not to constitute 'unequivocal admissions' as to the identity of the borrower where the unchallenged oral evidence of the lender's witnesses supported a personal loan, and where the documents were explicable in context as loosely drawn without precision as to the borrower's identity. The commercial context — that the lender understood the borrower to be personally wealthy and asset-rich, and made no enquiries into the company's financial position — provided objective support for the finding that the loan was personal. A borrower's statement during negotiations that he would repay within two months, when the agreed term was three months, was characterised as mere puffery and not a contractual term.
The full text is available to signed-in members.