stay pending application for special leave to appeal to High Court
Quick Take
1Assessing prospects of obtaining special leave to appeal is an impressionistic exercise; unanimity of opinion across multiple decision-makers and treating doctors, combined with the absence of any contrary expert evidence, significantly weakens prospects where the challenge is to an evaluative factual conclusion
2That refusal of a stay will render a special leave application nugatory is a significant but not determinative consideration; it does not outweigh the balance of convenience where the patient's condition is drug-resistant, causing prolonged suffering and escalating problematic behaviour, and delay has already been substantial
3Where a statutory provision (here s 96(3)(b)(ii) of the Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW)) is not replicated in other jurisdictions and has been unanimously construed for the first time by the Court of Appeal, the absence of any inter-court conflict weakens the case for special leave