CIVIL PROCEDURE — registrars — review of registrar’s decision — application by non-party to set aside orders refusing filing of notice of motion and dismissing proceeding as incompetent — applicant sought substitution for deregistered corporation in application for leave to appeal against winding-up order — whether interests of justice favour intervention — no utility in permitting filing of motion seeking to restrain deregistration where deregistration had already occurred — application dismissed
CORPORATIONS — deregistration — company deregistered after commencement of application for leave to appeal — company ceased to exist — company’s property, including any cause of action, vested in ASIC — former director and shareholder sought to be substituted as applicant — distinction between rights of company and personal rights of former director and shareholder — applicant lacked standing to assert rights belonging to company — proposed challenge to deregistration constituted new and different application
APPEALS — procedural fairness — hearing rule — registrar dismissed proceeding in chambers — applicant given opportunity to address capacity to act for company and declined invitation to apply in personal capacity — no denial of procedural fairness — any denial rectified by hearing de novo on review
COSTS — costs follow the event — asserted public interest and novelty insufficient to displace usual order — unsuccessful applicant ordered to pay respondent’s costs
Quick Take
1A former director and sole shareholder of a deregistered company lacks standing to be substituted as applicant in proceedings previously brought by the company, because the company's rights (including any cause of action) are distinct from the personal rights of its officers and vest in ASIC upon deregistration under s 601AD of the Corporations Act.
2An attempt to challenge a company's deregistration by ASIC within an existing application for leave to appeal against a winding-up order constitutes a new and different application (properly an application for reinstatement under s 601AH), raising separate factual and legal issues that do not properly arise in the appellate proceeding.
3Any denial of procedural fairness by a registrar deciding a matter in chambers is rectified by the de novo hearing available on review under s 121(3) of the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW) and UCPR r 49.19.