DAMAGES — exemplary damages — whether trial judge erred in awarding exemplary damages — basis for award of exemplary damages — whether [name withheld] obligation was breached by provision of CCTV footage to media — whether conduct of civil proceedings formed appropriate basis for award of exemplary damages
TORTS — intentional torts — assault and battery — altercation between plaintiff and defendant — whether primary judge erred in relation to factual findings
Quick Take
1The [name withheld] obligation cannot be found to have been breached where it is not established that the material in question was obtained under compulsion; the mere assumption that CCTV footage was compulsorily produced is insufficient to ground the obligation.
2Even if the [name withheld] obligation attached to material produced on compulsion, it ceases to apply once that material has been played or referred to in open court in a way that discloses its contents, particularly where it must have been understood by all parties that the material would be tendered in evidence — formal marking as an exhibit is not the exclusively determinative event.
3A finding that a witness exaggerated symptoms to medical practitioners does not compel rejection of that witness's evidence on other topics; a trial judge may accept evidence as to the incident causing injury while rejecting aspects of evidence as to the consequences of that injury, and an appellate court will not disturb such assessments absent demonstrated error.
Case Details
Citation[2026] NSWCA 153
CourtNSWCA
JurisdictionNew South Wales
Unlock so much more with Barrister AI
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.
1 of the 1 citing case carries a classified treatment. How each court treated it is available to signed-in members.