APPEALS — leave to appeal — principles governing — whether question of principle or matter of public importance or reasonably clear injustice demonstrated — where appeal involves matter of practice and procedure — leave refused
COSTS — security for costs — discretion — where claim in probate — where applicant resides in United Kingdom with no assets in Australia — consideration of history of litigation between parties — relevance of asserted impecuniosity — whether security orders would stultify proceedings
Quick Take
1An applicant for leave to appeal from a discretionary security for costs order must demonstrate arguable House v The King error; disagreement with the weight given to relevant factors, or the outcome of the court's consideration, does not establish such error.
2Where a party residing overseas has a demonstrated history of taking every available point to resist enforcement of costs orders in foreign jurisdictions, a primary judge is entitled to find a real risk justifying security for costs beyond the mere fact of overseas residence, even where reciprocal enforcement mechanisms exist.
3Assertions of impecuniosity on a leave application that are inconsistent with the case as run below — where the applicant relied on surplus equity in properties to resist security — do not demonstrate error in the primary judge's reasoning.