JUDICIAL REVIEW — review of decision of Judicial Commission of New South Wales — decision to refer a complaint by the Attorney General of New South Wales to Conduct Division of the Judicial Commission pursuant to Judicial Officers Act 1986 (NSW), s 21(1) — where the Chief Judge of the Local Court the subject of the June complaint was excluded from deliberation or decision of the August complaint — where board papers relevant to the August complaint were sent to the Chief Judge by administrative error — where communication occurred between the Chief Judge and a member of the Judicial Commission referring to board papers — whether decision affected by apprehended bias
Quick Take
1The Judicial Commission's obligation under s 21 of the Judicial Officers Act 1986 (NSW) to refer a complaint to the Conduct Division carries an ancillary duty to turn its corporate mind to s 20 and either form or not form a summary-dismissal opinion. Legal error in that non-formation requires the consequential s 21 referral to be set aside.
2Apprehended bias may arise on the facts where a commission member properly excluded from deliberations is inadvertently sent the papers and communicates a view about them to a participating member. If that communication is undisclosed and the decision does not record whether it was unanimous or by majority, a fair-minded lay observer might apprehend that the body was diverted from its intended impartial course. Following LPDT v Minister for Immigration (2024) 280 CLR 321, such apprehended bias is jurisdictional error irrespective of its actual effect on the decision.
3The Court expressly left open the 'vexed question' of when apprehended bias on the part of one member of an administrative body affects the body as a whole (cf McGovern v Ku-ring-gai Council (2008) 72 NSWLR 504; Isbester v Knox City Council (2015) 255 CLR 135). It proceeded on the narrow basis agreed by the parties.