APPEALS — interpretation of registration standards — where appellant’s application for registration as a Chinese medical practitioner refused — whether the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal misinterpreted the English Language Standard and the Recency of Practice Standard — no misinterpretation shown
PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS — where appellant alleges he was denied procedural fairness by the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal — no procedural unfairness shown
HUMAN RIGHTS — international law — where International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights does not apply — expressly rebutted by the words of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW) No 86a of 2009
COSTS — where no basis for leave to appeal against costs orders shown — impecuniosity of an unsuccessful party is no reason to depart from the general rule
Quick Take
1Under the advanced education pathway of the AHPRA English Language Skills Registration Standard, 'six years in total of (full-time equivalent) education' counts only academic periods in which the applicant successfully completes a course load meeting the provider's definition of full-time enrolment. Aggregating part-time study over a longer period to reach six years does not satisfy it. A 'break' means a break in full-time equivalent study, so part-time study counts towards the maximum two-year aggregate break.
2Registration standards developed by National Boards and approved by the Ministerial Council are construed by reference to text, context and purpose, including the public-protection objects of the National Law. Because they are not drafted by legislative drafters, they are construed practically, and their construction may be treated as a question of law.
3The 'recent graduate' exemption in the Chinese Medicine Recency of Practice Standard turns on qualifying from an 'approved program of study' as defined in s 5 of the National Law. Qualifications that count as 'advanced education' under the English Language Standard do not thereby become approved programs, because the two standards serve different objectives. Separately, the ICESCR, which is unincorporated, does not import proportionality reasoning into registration decisions given the paramountcy of public protection in s 3A of the National Law.