CRIME — appeals — alleged jurisdictional error — where applicant convicted and sentenced in the Local Court for offences against the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 1988 (NSW) — where notices of motion to set aside convictions and sentence dismissed by the District Court — whether District Court acted ultra vires — where no jurisdictional error shown
APPEALS — procedural fairness — bias or apprehension of bias — whether District Court denied applicant procedural fairness and gave reasonable apprehension of bias — where no denial of procedural fairness, reasonable apprehension of bias or jurisdictional error shown
Quick Take
1Clause 46 of Pt 18 of Sch 4 of the ICAC Act, which retrospectively validates proceedings commenced by an ICAC officer in accordance with written DPP advice, does not limit ICAC's functions or affect proceedings that were already valid when commenced; ICAC Act offences validly commenced in 2011, before s 14A of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) required written DPP advice, remain valid irrespective of whether such advice existed.
2A party who, through counsel, mounted a narrowly framed challenge to the validity of the commencement of a prosecution is bound by that forensic choice; a later challenge that the court attendance notices were never properly filed, which could have been raised earlier, would be barred by Anshun estoppel.
3A judge who stands down a self-represented applicant's motion to a specified time affords procedural fairness and may determine it in the applicant's absence if the applicant fails to attend and declines to appear remotely; a judge's description of a submission as 'very interesting', made after a full day's hearing, connotes scepticism but would not cause a fair-minded observer to apprehend a failure to decide on the merits.