WORKERS COMPENSATION — where worker catastrophically injured while fruit picking in Hillston, New South Wales — where employer’s principal place of business was Melbourne — where New South Wales workers compensation insurer accepted worker’s claim and made weekly payments of compensation to worker and on his behalf — where Victorian workers compensation insurer later accepted liability and commenced payment of compensation to worker — where New South Wales insurer sought recovery from Victorian insurer of compensation payments made to or on behalf or worker
RESTITUTION — workers compensation — statutory scheme for recovery of double compensation — whether New South Wales insurer had right of recovery from worker of compensation erroneously paid to him — whether retention by Victorian insurer of the value of the benefit notionally received by it unjust
UNJUST ENRICHMENT — restitution — where New South Wales insurer maintained that the payments of workers compensation made to injured worker were made by mistake — whether Victorian insurer unjustly enriched by or to the extent of payments made to the worker in satisfaction of Victorian insurer’s statutory obligation to pay worker — where no payments made to, or received by, Victorian insurer
Quick Take
1A plaintiff has a prima facie right to restitution from a defendant where (1) it pays a third party in the mistaken belief that it is liable to that third party, (2) the payment is neither requested by the defendant nor made under compulsion, but (3) the payment confers an incontrovertible benefit on the defendant by discharging or reducing its own liability to the third party, relieving it of a necessary expense. This holds at least where the discharge occurs by operation of statute and the defendant is a public authority. A request is not an essential element of all third-party restitution claims; its usual significance lies in whether the defendant's liability is actually discharged.
2WCA s 9AC(2) applies only where the interstate compensation is 'for the same matter', meaning each payment compensates the worker in the same respect. It was not engaged where the NSW and Victorian payments covered distinct periods, and neither the NSW nor the Victorian scheme excludes, by construction or for reasons of coherence, a general law restitutionary claim between the two scheme authorities.
3A mistaken payment is 'voluntary', in the David Securities sense of satisfying an honest claim, only where the payer makes a conscious decision to pay regardless of its legal obligation. On the facts, an insurer that investigated and then positively believed itself liable was mistaken, not voluntary. A restitutionary payment by VWA to iCare is 'compensation' for the purposes of the WIRCA s 369 indemnity, so no change of position defence arose from loss of that indemnity; a speculative Anshun estoppel arising after notice of the claim also cannot found the defence.