SENTENCING — Appeal against sentence — Backdating commencement of sentence — Whether bail conditions and attendance at rehabilitation amounted to quasi-custody — No error of fact or principle
Quick Take
1Whether bail conditions or participation in a residential rehabilitation program amount to quasi-custody is a finding of fact, which the offender must establish on the balance of probabilities and which must be reasonably open to the sentencing judge; it depends on the conditions imposed and on whether, and to what extent, they constrain the offender's liberty.
2Even where quasi-custody is found, there is no mandatory requirement to backdate the sentence and no set rate or percentage of allowance. Whether, and to what extent, backdating is allowed is discretionary and reviewable only on House v The King principles. The 50% (R v Eastway) and 75% (R v Cartwright) allowances are fact-specific and have not been applied generally, especially in recent times.
3Attendance at non-residential rehabilitation program sessions is not, and cannot be regarded as, quasi-custody. On the facts, credit of three months for 43 days of actual custody, eight days of residential detoxification and initially strict but progressively relaxed bail conditions disclosed no error of fact or principle.