The Court of Criminal Appeal held that where a sentencing judge's views on a contested issue (here, rejection of a psychiatric diagnosis) were clearly expressed in a first sentence judgment, and the judge flagged at a directions hearing that absent further submissions she was unlikely to change her findings on resentence, there was no procedural unfairness in maintaining those findings when defence counsel chose not to re-agitate the issue. The Court also held that robust judicial comments expressing frustration at having a matter remitted rather than resentenced by the appellate court, and preliminary indications of likely findings expressed as tentative views, did not give rise to apprehended bias. Additionally, the Court confirmed that a factual finding by one District Court judge rejecting a psychiatric diagnosis does not bind a different District Court judge in subsequent sentencing proceedings.
The full text is available to signed-in members.