The Court of Criminal Appeal held that a sentencing judge does not err by observing that rolled-up charges confer a benefit on an offender, provided the judge assesses the overall offending conduct captured by the charges rather than merely the number of charges. The Court also held that where defence counsel expressly conceded at sentencing that the rolled-up charges were beneficial, the applicant was precluded from raising a contrary argument on appeal. Judicial Commission statistics and a handful of purportedly comparable cases were found to be of limited assistance in establishing manifest excess, particularly where the comparator cases involved materially different circumstances.
The full text is available to signed-in members.