The Court held that a sentencing judge's finding that the offender committed offences anticipating his Parkinson's disease would shield him from sentence, made without giving the offender an opportunity to address the issue, constituted a denial of procedural fairness causing practical injustice where the finding was adverse and lacked any evidentiary foundation. The Court further held that aggregate sentencing does not relieve judges from applying totality principles, and that where indicative sentences are not lenient and the offences are closely connected as parts of a single criminal enterprise, a significant degree of notional concurrence is required — the absence of non-parole period components in indicative sentences creates a capacity for the sentencing process to be distorted by permitting a degree of cumulation that would not have been achievable with individual sentences. The original aggregate sentence of 3 years 3 months was found manifestly excessive and reduced to 2 years 9 months.
The full text is available to signed-in members.