The Court of Criminal Appeal held that s 285(1) of the Migration Act creates a single offence of advertising, with 'directly or indirectly' describing the means by which the prohibited conduct occurs rather than creating two separate offences, and accordingly the counts were not bad for duplicity. The Court also held that the trial judge erred in excluding documentary evidence under s 138 of the Evidence Act, finding that the conclusion of reckless impropriety in the use of a password to access business computers was based on impermissible speculation that did not meet the [name withheld] standard, particularly where the officers were not cross-examined on the alleged impropriety despite being offered for that purpose. The Crown's appeal on the s 146 CPA disclosure ruling was dismissed because the s 5F(3A) threshold was not met, as the excluded Parish Patience evidence was not shown to eliminate or substantially weaken the prosecution case given other available evidence.
The full text is available to signed-in members, including the 1 later case that cites this judgment.