The Court held that property owners who excluded a builder from the site in breach of the contract's access provisions could not subsequently purport to terminate the contract for the builder's alleged breaches, where the owners' breach was of an essential term and had a clear causal relationship with the builder's alleged defaults. The distinction between defective work and merely incomplete work was critical: where the contract remained on foot because termination was ineffective, items that the builder could have remedied had access not been denied were characterised as incomplete works rather than actionable defects, significantly reducing the damages recoverable. Damages were awarded only for agreed and proven defects ($25,102.22), with claims for cost to complete, rent, and items classified as incomplete work rejected.
The full text is available to signed-in members.