The Court refused a stay of execution of a judgment obtained under s 25 of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW), holding that the policies of the SOP Act — maintaining cash flow and placing insolvency risk on the principal — carried significant weight and were not displaced by the respondent's post-adjudication payment to the claimant's subcontractor or by weak evidence of defective works. The Court found that the respondent's payment to Lindsay Civil, which post-dated the payment claim and adjudication, could not justify a stay as it would indirectly allow the respondent to achieve a result that ss 16(4) and 25(4) prohibited directly, and the absence of any insolvency contention further militated against a stay. The Court applied Black Label Developments v McMenemy [2025] NSWCA 114, confirming that while SOP Act policies do not absolutely preclude a stay, the circumstances here were not sufficiently exceptional to warrant one.
The full text is available to signed-in members.