The Court dismissed a self-represented plaintiff's recusal application based on apprehended bias, holding that evaluative findings made in an earlier preliminary discovery judgment concerning the same litigant did not give rise to a reasonable apprehension that the judge could not impartially case-manage a separate defamation proceeding. The Court emphasised that impressionistic views formed in interlocutory procedural decisions about the apparent weaknesses of prospective claims are fundamentally different from final findings on credit or fraud, and that a party with repeat litigation cannot secure removal of a judge merely by appealing an adverse procedural decision and asserting overlap in subject matter. Judicial interventions during a hearing, including inquiries about AI use in submissions, were held not to evidence bias when considered individually or cumulatively.
The full text is available to signed-in members.